Understanding Email Retention Laws: A Comprehensive Guide

Navigating email retention laws can be a complex and challenging process. With different regulations for different industries and the ever-increasing importance of data privacy, it can be difficult to know where to start. In this guide, we'll provide an overview of email retention laws and the legal requirements for retaining different types of data. We'll also examine key retention laws by industry and look at some of the common challenges that come with complying with email retention regulations.

What are Email Retention Laws

Email retention laws are in place to ensure that businesses protect sensitive information and meet legal requirements. These regulations are constantly evolving, and it's crucial for organizations to stay informed about the latest updates to avoid costly penalties and reputational damage.

It's not just about the laws though: compliance with email retention laws can also help businesses build trust with customers and stakeholders, demonstrating their commitment to data privacy and security. 

United States: The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) require companies to retain email communications that may be relevant to a legal matter for a period of time. The specific retention period varies depending on the nature of the legal matter and may range from several months to several years.

European Union: The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requires companies that collect and process personal data of EU citizens to retain email communications for as long as necessary to fulfill the purpose for which the data was collected. Remember that this covers organizations that are based outside of the EU but that collect/process data of EU citizens.

Canada: The Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) requires companies to retain email communications for as long as necessary to fulfill the purpose for which the data was collected. This may include retaining emails for a certain period of time after a business relationship has ended, such as for tax or legal purposes.

United Kingdom: The Data Protection Act 2018 requires companies to retain email communications for as long as necessary to fulfill the purpose for which the data was collected. This may include retaining emails for a certain period of time after a business relationship has ended, such as for tax or legal purposes.

Legal Requirements for Email Retention

The legal requirements for email retention vary by country and industry, but in general, companies are required to retain email communications for a certain period of time in order to comply with legal and regulatory requirements. Here are some common legal requirements for email retention:

Compliance with industry-specific regulations: Businesses like yours, may be subject to industry-specific regulations that require you to retain email communications for a certain period of time. For example, the healthcare industry in the United States is subject to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), which requires the retention of certain types of patient information, including email communications, for at least six years.

Compliance with legal requirements: Companies may be required to retain email communications in order to comply with legal requirements related to litigation, investigations, or audits. For example, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) in the United States require companies to retain email communications that may be relevant to a legal matter.  In general, email communications that may be relevant to a legal matter should be retained for the duration of the legal matter, including any appeals or potential future litigation. However, if your business is potentially impacted by this situation, check with legal counsellor for the exact requirements in your particular scenario.

Business purposes: Companies may choose to retain email communications for business purposes, such as customer service, compliance monitoring, or record-keeping. In these cases, the retention period can be determined by the company's internal policies and procedures.

Overall, email retention periods for business purposes may vary depending on the nature of the business, industry-specific regulations, and the company's internal policies and procedures. 

Key Retention Laws by Industry

Next we'll examine key retention laws by industry and discuss some of the common challenges that come with complying with email retention regulations. Whether you're in healthcare, finance, government, or any other industry, it's critical to understand the legal requirements for email retention and implement robust retention policies and procedures. 

Healthcare Sector and HIPAA Regulations

The healthcare sector is highly regulated, and email communications are subject to specific retention requirements under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in the United States. HIPAA regulations govern the privacy and security of protected health information (PHI) and apply to healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses, as well as their business associates.

HIPAA requires covered entities and their business associates to retain email communications that contain PHI for a minimum of six years from the date of creation or the date it was last in effect, whichever is later. This retention period applies to email communications that are used for treatment, payment, and healthcare operations. It is important to note that the six-year retention period is a minimum requirement, and covered entities and business associates may choose to retain the data for longer periods of time.

Financial Sector and SEC/FINRA Regulations

The financial sector is also highly regulated, and email communications are subject to specific retention requirements under regulations set by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) in the United States. These regulations aim to protect investors and maintain the integrity of the financial markets.

The SEC requires broker-dealers to retain email communications for a minimum of three years, with the first two years in an easily accessible location. The retention period applies to all email communications that are used for business purposes, including communications with customers and other broker-dealers, and applies to both incoming and outgoing emails.

FINRA also requires broker-dealers to retain email communications for a minimum of three years, but requires the first two years of emails to be stored in a write-once, read-many (WORM) format to ensure that the emails cannot be altered or deleted. The retention period applies to all email communications that are used for business purposes, including communications with customers and other broker-dealers, and applies to both incoming and outgoing emails.

Whichever geography (or geographies) that your business operates in, check with local legal counsellor to determine the regulations that you must follow.

Government Sector and FOIA Regulations

The government sector is subject to specific retention requirements under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) in the United States. FOIA regulations require federal agencies to retain email communications that are considered to be records of the agency for a minimum of three years. This retention period applies to email communications that are used for administrative, legal, or historical purposes.

Compliance with FOIA regulations can be a challenge for government agencies, as they must balance the need for transparency and accountability with the need to protect sensitive information. Agencies must also ensure that they are retaining the correct types of email communications and that they are able to retrieve and produce them in a timely manner in response to FOIA requests.

To navigate these challenges, government agencies may implement robust email retention policies and procedures, including regular training for employees on the importance of email retention and the requirements of FOIA regulations. Agencies may also use email archiving solutions to streamline the retention and retrieval of email communications.

Common Challenges with Email Retention Compliance

While email retention is critical for compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, it can also be a complex and challenging process for organizations. Here are some common challenges that companies may face when it comes to email retention compliance:

Lack of clarity on retention requirements: The legal and regulatory requirements for email retention can be complex and vary by country and industry. Companies may struggle to understand the specific requirements that apply to their business and may inadvertently fail to retain important email communications.

Inconsistent retention policies: Companies may have inconsistent retention policies that vary by department, geography or employee. This can lead to confusion and make it difficult to ensure that all email communications are being retained appropriately. Ensure that the policies in your organization are fully documented and audited.

Technical challenges: Email retention can be technically challenging, particularly for organizations that have large volumes of email communications. Companies may struggle to manage and store email data in a way that is compliant with legal and regulatory requirements.

Most companies which are affected by regulations and have requirements described in this blog implement email archiving. Click for more information on the importance of email archiving and compliance.

Cost considerations: Email retention can be expensive, particularly for organizations that need to retain large volumes of data for long periods of time. Companies may need to invest in additional storage and archiving solutions to ensure that they are able to retain email communications in a compliant manner.

Store your long term archive in the cloud. Find out how Expireon can help.

Human error: Despite the best intentions, employees may inadvertently delete or fail to retain important email communications. This can be particularly problematic in industries that are highly regulated and subject to strict retention requirements. For this reason automated email journal archiving is required by most large organizations.

Navigating email retention laws can be challenging, but it is crucial for businesses to comply with legal and regulatory requirements to protect sensitive information and build trust with customers and stakeholders. By implementing robust retention policies and procedures, companies can ensure that important data is retained for the required period and avoid costly penalties and reputational damage.

Understanding the legal requirements for email retention and complying with them can be complex and challenging, but it is necessary for companies in almost all industries.